C3 vs C4 vs CAM
C3
|
C4
|
CAM
|
|
In hot
areas
|
Cons: shut their stomata (stopping
CO2 entry) and increase photorespiration as temperature increase
|
Pros: overcome the tendency of
photorespiration by using a more efficient enzyme to fix CO2 in and shuttles
fixed carbon via malate or aspartate to bundle-sheath cells. In these
bundle-sheath cells, RuBisCO is isolated from atmospheric oxygen and
saturated with the CO2 (released by decarboxylation of the malate). Cons:
additional steps, however, require more ATP.
|
|
Examples
|
most small seeded cereal crops such as rice (Oryza
sativa), wheat (Triticum spp.), barley (Hordeum vulgare),
rye (Secale cereale), and oat (Avena sativa); soybean (Gycine
max), peanut (Arachis hypogaea), cotton (Gossypium spp.),
sugar beets (Beta vulgaris), tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum),
spinach (Spinacea oleracea), potato (Solanum tuberosum)
|
Corn
|
Pineapple,
agave
|
Pros
|
More efficient than under cool and moist conditions and normal
light because requires less machinery (fewer enzymes and no specialized
anatomy)
|
Fast growing in warm/dry areas
Minimize photorespiration
Photosynthesizes faster than C3 plants
under high light intensity and high temperatures because the CO2 is delivered
directly to RUBISCO, not allowing it to grab oxygen and undergo
photorespiration. Has better Water Use Efficiency because PEP Carboxylase
brings in CO2 faster and so does not need to keep stomata open as much (less
water lost by transpiration) for the same amount of CO2 gain for
photosynthesis.
|
Fast growing in hot/dry areas
Minimize photorespiration
Fix CO2 at night
Better Water Use
Efficiency than C3 plants under arid conditions due to opening stomata at
night when transpiration rates are lower (no sunlight, lower temperatures,
lower wind speeds, etc.). When conditions are extremely arid, CAM plants can
just leave their stomata closed night and day. CAM-idle: Oxygen given off in
photosynthesis is used for respiration and CO2 given off in respiration is
used for photosynthesis. This is a little like a perpetual energy machine,
but there are costs associated with running the machinery for respiration and
photosynthesis so the plant cannot CAM-idle forever. CAM-idling does allow
the plant to survive dry spells, and it allows the plant to recover very
quickly when water is available again (unlike plants that drop their leaves
and twigs and go dormant during dry spells).
|
Cons
|
Needs more
ATP
|
Stomata open
only at night
|
|
Enzyme
|
Rubisco
|
Pep carboxylase
|
Pep carboxylase
|
Comentarios
Publicar un comentario